Neddy Nebuliser and the Nerdy Spreadsheet

First Posted 17th May 2016

Later this week I’m off to spend a few days at the Royal Brompton as my participation in a clinical trial comes to an end. I thought for this post I’d write about the trial, Neddy Nebuliser and my particularly nerdy spreadsheet that it has prompted me to create.

Clinical trials are awesome things. They are the foundation of the incremental improvements in health that have seen the average lifespan dramatically increase in recent history. A good trial will tell you if a new pill, or treatment is better for a patient than doing nothing or giving them homeopathy or a placebo (sorry, I just repeated myself there). Crucially in these days where accountants have been set to rule over us all as the arbiters of moral propriety, a good trial can show whether it is worth opening their wallets to pay for a treatment (of course that is whole other discussion – one that I’m not going to enter into here!).

A bad trial will, at best, tell you want you want to discover not the truth. This can lead to poor treatment and spending decisions. At worst it will provide a veneer of pseudo-science with which to beguile and mislead the unwary.

After that diversion you’ll no doubt be pleased to hear I’m in a good trial! It’s a type known as a double-blind, double-dummy. For twelve weeks I took drugs from Box A. I then stopped for a week, and was given a different, but identical looking, box of drugs (Box B) which I took for another twelve weeks. One of those boxes was full of the real drug, and one was full of a placebo. (That’s the double-dummy bit). Whether Box A or Box B contained the placebo is noted somewhere, but neither I nor the clinicians administering the trial have access to it. The only way I can tell if I’m taking the real drug is by (hopefully) finding that I can walk further and get less breathless when taking one and not the other (That’s the double-blind bit).

You can read much better explanations than I can give of Clinical Trials at and their benefits, risks and abuses at Ben Goldacre’s excellent blog Bad Science.

The major benefit (for me at least) of the trial is that having started on the drug, if the drug is effective, I can’t have the treatment taken away once the trial is over if I still want it.  All being well I get to stay on the drug I’ve been using for the trial. Why is this good (aside from the medical benefit)? Well it comes back to those pesky wallets. The NHS will only pay for me to have two of the class of drugs this one fall into. I’m already taking two, so by starting it through a trial I gain a third treatment I wouldn’t routinely eligible for.

Now if that’s seeming like I’m unfairly getting more than my share of the NHS funds, well, possibly. To be honest though that ship probably sailed over 30 years ago.

Also there’s a chance it won’t be the NHS funding the drug, but rather the company supplying the drug. They’ll see it as a part of the cost of expanding their market for the drug. The pharmaceutical company pays for my treatment (Or at least a portion of it e.g. the first X years.) on the basis that they can now, thanks to the trial, sell the drug to a whole bunch of other patients (though given the parameters of the trial, it’s probably not a particularly large bunch!).  Don’t quote me on this; I don’t know if this is the case in this study, as I’m not privy to the financial ins and outs of it – I’m just a patient after all! I know it has been done on other clinical trials though.

The actual drug being studied is inhaled Ilaprost, it’s a drug that is well used for treating Pulmonary Hypertension (PHT) where the PHT is the primary condition. The study is looking at whether it will be beneficial in cases like myself where the PHT is a secondary effect of another heart condition (Which in my case is Eisenmengers Syndrome).

Inhaled Ilaprost is delivered through a natty little device called a Nebuliser. I’ve called mine Neddy (I’m not sure why its a boy. Mostly it’s name was selected for the alliteration).  Here’s a picture of him:

A picture of Neddy Nebuliser
A picture of Neddy Nebuliser

Neddy is pretty special because he’s hand held and most nebulisers aren’t. This means I can take Neddy out and about with me which is important as I have to take the Ilaprost six times a day – at 7:00am, 10:00am, 1:00pm, 4:00pm, 7:00pm & 10:00pm. I have a lot of alarms set on my phone to keep track of it all!

Everything I need to use Neddy. Clockwise from Top Left. Mouthpiece, Main body, Ampule of Drug/Placebo, Ampule snapper, pipette, Filter, funnel and Dose Well/Filter Clasp.
All the bits I use to take one dose. Clockwise from top left. Mouthpiece, main body, ampule of drug/placebo, ampule snapper, pipette, filter, funnel and dose well & filter Clasp.

To use Neddy I load the drug from a little glass ampule into a well in the top of the machine and seal it with a filter. You can see a picture of the parts involved in taking a dose below

I then put the nozzle in my mouth and breathe in and out deeply for about 20 minutes. Every time I breathe in the mechanism vibrates and turns a little bit of the drug it’s loaded with into vapour, which I then inhale. Once the correct dose has been delivered a tone sounds and the vibrating stops.

Neddy in use
Neddy in use

I think it looks like an e-cigarette, if it had been made by the soviet bloc in the 1970s. Friends have said I sound like Darth Vader when using it (though there’s less speaking and I have not yet managed to throttle anyone with the power of my mind). My wife tracks where I am in the house by the sound of it.

party blower
An addition I need to try out

She also thinks I should get a party blower (see the picture on the left…) to attach to the vent at the top of Neddy, so that when I exhale it unfurls, tooting.

I think it would be pretty cool too. Maybe I’ll do it and post a video.

Once a day I have to wash all the filters (I have 6) and the well piece I’ve used during the day. It has to be in soft or filtered water, because the filters are a microscopic mesh and the impurities in hard water can cause the mesh to clog up, which is bad. At least once a week I have to boil wash the parts. The local water is very hard, and despite always using filtered water I’ve had problems so I tend to boil wash my kit every day.

Using Neddy for the past 6 months has been interesting. The six times a day usage strangely gives a great deal of structure to the day. Though there is some leeway on the timings and it’s OK to miss the occasional dose, I’ve done my best not to. As It’s part of a clinical trial there is a compliance level, which means I have to take at least eighty percent of the doses scheduled. At the time of posting I have (by my own calculations admittedly) a 94.1% compliance. My tendency toward OCD and perhaps competitiveness means I’m up a 07:00am every day for my first puff (though I tend to use the term ‘breathing’). I organise appointments where I can around the times I have to stop and breathe. For example, I’ll arrange a haircut at 11:00am not 10:00am or GP appointment for 03:00pm not 04:00pm. When I’m really organised, I’ll get my diary out whilst breathing at 7am and work out my days’ schedule around the doses.

Neddy has proved relatively unobtrusive. My friends have been good enough to sit through my ‘breathing’ and chat among themselves – something that’s not a problem for twenty minutes. It’s the odd occasion where it has taken much longer that one starts to feel self-conscious.

I was very nervous of using Neddy in public initially, fearing censure from other people, who (in my mind) would inevitably think I was taking some heinous illegal drugs or using an e-cigarette in a no smoking area and take me to task for it. I must have had a guilty conscience or something. Now, I have no Idea why I though that – I’ll pretty much whip Neddy out anywhere, even travelling. Needless to say I can’t actually drive whilst using Neddy, but if I’m a passenger and there aren’t too many pot holes or hairpin bends I can set things up whilst we’re moving and the dose delivery itself is no problem.

Neddy in his travelling box
Neddy in his travelling box

I think I get the odd small child looking at me curiously, and everyone else is pretty much oblivious to it. In fact, I’m almost disappointed. I was looking forward to self-righteously remonstrating with a would be busy body about it. I was so nervous about it that the first time I did use the nebuliser when I was out I was actually shedding tears of gratitude whilst thanking the staff f the coffee shop I was in for allowing me to use it in their premises.

Having read the title, you may be wondering about the Nerdy spreadsheet by now. Well it’s like this. As a trial, I have to record the doses I use on a sheet, ticking off that I’ve taken them and noting any doses I’ve missed and why. I’d been doing a few weeks  when I began to notice that the time it took to complete a dose seemed to be about 10 minutes longer than it had been.

Being of a slightly scientific mind-set, I decided to start tracking the phenomenon. Initially I just wrote the times down on the form instead of putting a tick. It was quite interesting, and strangely motivating.

I would occasionally get really poor time and my data analysing mind then thought “I wonder if these times are caused by a particular filter?”. So I started noting the time and which filter I’d used.

The final step to the Dark Side came when I realised that what I really needed was to track my times on a spreadsheet. So was born My Nerdy Spreadsheet – so called because one of the Health Care Professionals on the trial team told me it was the sort of thing a nerd like me would do. I’m not sure I really qualify as a nerd, but I’ll take the compliment.

The problem with Nerdy spreadsheets is, they grow. So I quickly saw that not only could I track average times and average time for each filter, but I could add graphs of the times across each week, calculate my compliance and many other things that I finally realised weren’t really necessary at all.

All the data did have a use though. When I had problems with the timings again, I was able to send the spreadsheet to the relevant people and it was clear what was happening (if not why!).

And now I can’t stop myself. The trial is coming to an end, and hopefully I will have been effective and I’ll be allowed go onto the real drug (called open label, as the vials will have the drug name on so I‘ll know that I’m taking it). And I’ll still maintain my spreadsheet. I’m not sure why, it just seems wrong not to. And you know, maybe that data will still be useful…

Until next time,

Skwerg